|
Tales of Terror and Detection by Edgar Allan Poe
Reader Reviews 2 of 2 people found the following review helpful: convenient and well-priced (supliment advised), July 24, 2002 Reviewer: Caroline Chapman from Chicago This little Dover edition is cheap and fits easily into any bag, which makes it good bus stop reading. There is, however, a disadvantage to this portable Poe; namely, it?s not all there. The collection excludes the story for which Poe is credited for having begun the detective genre itself: ?The Murders in the Rue Morgue? introduces the characters of Dupin and our narrator, and prepares the scene for the detective figure to fill the gap of reasoning that the overly-methodical Parisian police have left. It sets the tone for the increased emphasis on analysis in ?Marie Rog?t? and the humorous rivalry between police and detective in ?The Purloined Letter.? That being said, the other stories fit well together; ?The Oblong Box? has one foot in the detective genre and the other in that species of psychological drama that we see in ?William Wilson.? Wilson and his doppelganger compliment the double corpse question in "Marie Rog?t," and the parallel worlds and coincidences, which make the mystery of Marie Rog?t more fascinating, lend an uncanny quality to ?MS Found in a Bottle,? with the discovery of Mercator?s map. If these stories show us anything about Poe, it is his ability to bring a story to a logical conclusion that still leaves an eerie taste in the reader?s mouth.
|
